Independent Contractor Versus Employee

The Department has issued regulations addressing how to analyze whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor under the FLSA (29 CFR part 795, effective March 11, 2024). Employees receive the protections of the FLSA. Independent contractors are in business for themselves and therefore are not covered by the FLSA.

The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) and other federal agencies, as well as many state governments, use specific criteria to distinguish between employees and independent contractors. These criteria help ensure that workers receive appropriate protections and benefits based on their classification. While there isn’t a single set of rules universally applied, the guidelines generally revolve around the degree of control an employer exercises over a worker. Here are some common factors considered:

Behavioral Control: This refers to the degree to which the employer controls how the work is performed. Factors include instructions given to the worker, training provided, and evaluation methods used. Employees typically receive detailed instructions on when, where, and how to work, while independent contractors have more autonomy in completing tasks.

Financial Control: This aspect examines the extent to which the worker has financial independence and investment in the tools and equipment necessary to perform the job. Independent contractors often invest in their own tools and bear the costs of running their business, while employees typically rely on the employer’s resources.

Type of Relationship: This factor looks at the nature of the relationship between the worker and the employer. Key considerations include written contracts, benefits provided, and the permanency of the relationship. Employees often have long-term relationships with their employers and receive benefits such as health insurance and paid leave, whereas independent contractors typically work on a project basis and are responsible for their own benefits.

Integration: This refers to how integral the worker’s services are to the employer’s business. If the worker’s services are essential to the regular operations of the business, they are more likely to be classified as an employee. Independent contractors usually provide services that are separate from the core activities of the employer.

It’s important to note that no single factor is determinative, and the classification depends on the overall relationship between the worker and the employer. Additionally, the criteria may vary depending on the specific laws and regulations of each jurisdiction. Misclassification of workers can lead to legal liabilities for employers, including penalties for unpaid taxes and benefits. Therefore, it’s essential for employers to carefully evaluate the nature of their relationships with workers to ensure compliance with relevant laws and regulations.

Employment-at-Will and Wrongful Termination Allegations

Employment-at-will is a legal doctrine in the United States that allows employers to terminate employees for any reason, at any time, as long as the reason is not prohibited by law. This means that employers have broad discretion to hire and fire employees, and employees likewise have the freedom to resign from their positions without facing legal consequences. However, this doctrine is not absolute, and there are limits to it, particularly when it comes to wrongful termination allegations.

Wrongful termination allegations typically arise when an employee believes they were fired in violation of laws or agreements that protect them from unjust dismissal. Here are some common scenarios where wrongful termination allegations may occur within the context of employment-at-will:

  • Discrimination: Employers cannot terminate employees based on protected characteristics such as race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, or genetic information. Wrongful termination claims may arise if an employee believes they were fired because of one of these protected characteristics, in violation of federal or state anti-discrimination laws.
  • Retaliation: Employees are protected from retaliation for engaging in certain legally protected activities, such as reporting discrimination or harassment, whistleblowing, or exercising their rights under labor laws. If an employee is terminated in retaliation for engaging in these activities, they may have grounds for a wrongful termination claim under various federal and state laws.
  • Violation of Public Policy: Wrongful termination claims can also arise when an employee is fired for reasons that violate public policy. For example, if an employee is terminated for refusing to engage in illegal activities, reporting illegal conduct, or exercising legal rights such as taking family or medical leave, the termination may be considered unlawful under the public policy exception to employment-at-will.
  • Implied Contracts: While employment-at-will is the default rule in most states, courts may recognize implied contracts that modify the at-will relationship. Implied contracts can arise from employer policies, employee handbooks, oral assurances of job security, or past practices. If an employer breaches an implied contract by firing an employee in violation of its terms, the employee may have a wrongful termination claim.
  • Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing: Some states recognize an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in employment relationships. This implies that employers must act in good faith when terminating employees, and they cannot terminate employees arbitrarily or in bad faith. Wrongful termination claims based on the breach of this covenant focus on the fairness and good faith of the employer’s actions. 
  • Statutory Protections and Whistleblower Laws: Employees who report violations of law or public policy by their employers may be protected by whistleblower laws. Wrongful termination claims may arise if an employee is fired for whistleblowing, as such terminations are often prohibited by law.

While employment-at-will provides employers with broad discretion to terminate employees, wrongful termination allegations can arise when terminations violate laws, public policy, implied contracts, or the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. Employers must be aware of these limits and ensure that terminations comply with applicable legal standards to avoid potential legal consequences.

 

 

Why do we have a lobbyist?

Why Associations Use Lobbyists: Advocacy in Action 

In the modern world of business and industry, trade associations play a vital role in representing their members’ interests. For sectors like the life safety and property protection industry, which includes companies specializing in security systems, fire alarms, and monitoring services, navigating the complex landscape of public policy and regulation is crucial. This is where the role of a lobbyist becomes invaluable. But why do alarm associations opt to use lobbyists?

At its core, a lobbyist acts as a representative and advocate for the interests of the alarm association and its members. Lobbyists are trained professionals skilled in communicating with policymakers, legislators, and regulators. They ensure that the concerns, needs, and viewpoints of the life safety and property protection industry are effectively presented and considered in the policymaking process. 

One of the primary objectives of hiring a lobbyist is to influence the development, modification, or defeat of policies, laws, and regulations that impact the life safety and property protection industry. Lobbyists leverage their expertise, industry knowledge, and relationships with decision-makers to shape favorable policies and regulations. 

Lobbyists often have established relationships with key legislators, government officials, and regulatory authorities. This access allows them to communicate directly with decision-makers, providing a platform for the alarm association’s concerns and priorities. Such direct communication can significantly enhance the association’s ability to influence and shape public policy. 

Keeping abreast of legislative and regulatory developments is crucial for any industry association. Lobbyists play a pivotal role in monitoring proposed legislation, regulatory changes, and policy initiatives that could impact the life safety and property protection industry. They gather relevant information, analyze its implications, and provide timely updates to the association, enabling them to stay informed and proactive. 

Collaboration can amplify advocacy efforts. Lobbyists can help alarm associations build coalitions with other industry stakeholders, interest groups, and organizations. By forming strategic partnerships, the association can strengthen its advocacy efforts, broaden its influence, and create a united front on key issues affecting the life safety and property protection industry. 

The use of lobbyists by associations is a strategic approach to advocacy that offers numerous benefits. From effective representation and influence on policy to access to decision-makers and information gathering, lobbyists play a crucial role in advancing the interests of the life safety and property protection industry. By harnessing the expertise, networks, and advocacy skills of lobbyists, alarm associations can navigate the complexities of the political landscape, shape favorable policies, and ensure the continued growth and success of their members. 

New False Alarm Chairperson

We are very excited to welcome Kevin Rocha as the False Alarm Chairperson for the LLSSA.  Kevin was appointed at the April board meeting.  Kevin works for Louisiana Special Systems and know the difficulty that we can face working with AHJ’s and will work with the LLSSA and industry stakeholders to drive positive change and enhance life safety measures in our communities.

Kevin told us, “I’m grateful for the opportunity to be part of an organization that is dedicated to advancing standards and fostering collaboration among industry professionals. I am eager to leverage the resources and expertise LLSSA offers to make a meaningful impact in addressing false alarms on security and fire systems across Louisiana.”
 
Kevin will be at the Dealer Conference in Natchitoches next month, so do be sure to shake his hand and welcome him to the Board.  Also, let him know of the concerns in your region so that he can begin to build his knowledge base and start to set a plan of action.  Most importantly if you have a passion for False Alarms and how to eliminate them, join his committee.  He will need people in every region to work together to get the word out and bring the information in.  
 
You can reach Kevin at 337-351-8862 or at email kevin.rocha@lss-online.com

Welcome New Member!

We would like to Welcome our newest Regular Member to the LLSSA.

American Technologies was voted into membership by the Board at the April Meeting.

They are a local, family-owned business that specializes in fire alarm, security, and other low voltage systems based in Metairie, LA.

Make sure you welcome them to the association the next time you see them.

10th Annual Dealer Conference

Don't miss the 10th Annual Dealer Conference

Join us May 22nd & 23rd for the 10th Annual Dealer Conference at Natchitoches Events Center.   This year we are excited to provide our attendees with 8 hours of CEU’s in either the Business or Technical Tracks over the day and a half.  Our State Meeting will feature current information from the State Fire Marshal’s Office, False Alarm Reduction Association and from Mapes and Mapes regarding legislation that is threatening our businesses.  There will also be 30+ vendors at the tradeshow and prizes for those whose number is chosen.  But it won’t be all work and no play, the Welcome Reception on Wednesday will be a time for you to catch up with old friends and participate in some friendly competition.

New this year is the Event Application.  This application gives you access to the event schedule on your phone.  You also have access to the speaker and vendors to ask questions and schedule appointments.  We will also use it to send push notifications to keep you on track and notified of changes in real time.  Plus, you can network with anyone in attendance that has agreed to network.

So don’t miss out.  The classes are better than ever.  The speakers for the State Meeting are going to be informative.  The tradeshow will offer access to industry professionals and their wares.  The app will keep you informed.  And, yes, the Welcome Reception will be playtime.  See you in just a few short weeks in Natchitoches.

Senate Bill 489

Are you aware of SB 489

Senate Bill 489 is sponsored by Senator Cathey.  This bill provides for the duties of the Louisiana State Fire Marshal was brough to our attention. We present it now to the membership to review and contact your representative.

This Bill in our reading attempts to:

  1. Eliminates all NFPA codes and inserts the ICC (International Code Council) which was first issued in 2000. NFPA is the gold standard in building codes and was established in 1896. Louisiana utilizes NFPA 101 – Life Safety Code to protect lives and property. 
  2. Eliminates Plan Review from one central office of the SFM office and pushes plan review, licensing and building inspections to over sixty-four different parishes and seven hundred municipalities. 
  3. Eliminates State Fire Marshal oversight of the High-Rise Fire Sprinkler Act. 
  4. Architects, engineers, contractors, subcontractors, owners, and developers will now need to contact each parish to obtain building requirements.
  5. Licensing for companies, inspectors, designers, technicians, etc. – How will this be managed? Sixty-four different licenses to perform work in all parishes? It is not even clear if they require licensing. 
  6. Insurance Companies run on Rules & Regulations. This will impact rates, premium options, and affordability for all. This will drive insurance companies out.
  7. Economic Impact to the State 
  8. Safety Standards – How many lives/properties are your risking with this change – yours, your family, your business.       LIVES ARE AT STAKE 

We need your help now!!!!

Examining Louisiana’s Constitution

Examining Louisiana's Constitution: The Impact on Business and Industry" A.k.a. open up your kimono, Louisiana!

This article presented by Joe Mapes the LLSSA Lobbyist

While I’m not opposed to the governor’s plan to hold a constitutional convention, I do question the timing. The 1973 constitutional convention took close to two years, and Louisiana is currently considering re-tooling our state’s most precious document in roughly two weeks. Is some voodoo magic going to occur within that two-week period, or is Louisiana‘s next Constitution already drafted? 

The delegate body will be comprised of legislators from both the senate and the house, as well as some individuals from the private sector. For this newly formed group to gather a consensus on so many complicated issues in such a short period of time will be next to impossible. It would be like trying to herd a bunch of cats in a room full of rocking chairs.

For decades, business and industry groups opposed a convention. Roughly 10 years ago, however, legislation was filed to call for a fiscal-matters-only constitutional convention, so business groups removed their opposition to a convention because the need to fix the state’s financial system was obvious to everyone. Several bills to create a convention have been filed since, but no bill has ever passed. Since no bills passed to create a convention, nobody looked very closely at the details, like is there even such a thing as a limited constitutional convention?  The answer is no. Sub-articles in the constitution cannot be opened by themselves. That’s because the sub-articles are under their parent article, and that main article has to be opened first. When a main article is opened, all of the contents of its sub-articles are opened thus exposing all of the related industries and professions in each sub-article. As stated by Senate President, Cameron Henry, “Once you’re in a Constitutional Convention, you open up the entire Constitution”. Sunday – The Advocate

Every industry and profession should be lobbying and educating the legislature right now, as roughly 2/3 of the delegates will come from the house and the senate. Business and industry groups need to educate potential delegates and answer questions about what’s important to their industry in the constitution, before any convention begins. There’s just not enough time before May or June to do this – especially during a legislative session. 

If business and industry groups are not able to educate the legislature as to what’s important to them in the Constitution prior to a convention, then who will educate the delegates? These delegates may not even know who they are right now, so they’re probably not burning the midnight oil studying all the issues that could possibly come up during a convention. A one-to-two-year period is needed so that business and industry have a chance to educate the delegates about the importance of their issues that are in the constitution. That way, when the Delegates walk into a constitutional convention, they’ll have a stack of folders filled with papers under their arms and be better prepared to do business with Louisiana’s most important document. 

If it’s possible that a new constitution has already been written and the delegates are just being handpicked to vote yes for a completely rewritten, new constitution for our state, then there was little to no input from the general public. If an entirely new constitution has been written in advance of any constitutional convention, then who wrote it? With issues like personal injury rights in the courts and the personal bill of rights being in the constitution, this seems like an extremely important question to have answered. 

As stated by House Speaker, Phillip DeVillier, he would like to create a Sub-Committee of Legislators to recommend the final shape of the Bill, adding that what it would contain “is on everyone’s mind”.  Sunday – The Advocate

 

Joe Mapes of Mapes & Mapes, Inc. – 225-268-8572 (cell)

Understanding Louisiana State Fire Marshal Memorandum 2019-01

In March 2019, the Louisiana State Fire Marshal issued Memorandum 2019-01, a directive aimed at enhancing fire safety measures across the state. This memorandum outlines crucial guidelines and regulations for various establishments, ensuring compliance and safeguarding against fire hazards. Understanding its provisions is essential for businesses, organizations, and individuals to prioritize fire safety and prevent potential disasters.

Key Provisions of Memorandum 2019-01:

 

1. Special locking Systems: The memorandum identifies the types of specialized locking systems as defined by the NFPA 101 Life Safety Code.  It also clarifies their use in required settings.

2. Electric Strikes and Latch Retracting Door Hardware: Interior Doors are required to be submitted to the SFMO for review prior to installation.  We bring this to your attention because this Memorandum does replace IM 2009-03 which stated otherwise.

 

3. Instructions for Plan Submittal for Special Locking Arrangements: The memorandum lists the information required for these types of submittals. Adhering to the list can make the process easier and faster for all parties involved.

 

Memorandum 2019-01 aligns with broader efforts to enhance fire safety standards and regulations at the state and national levels. By setting clear guidelines and expectations, it empowers stakeholders to take proactive measures to prevent fires and minimize their impact on communities.

Two House Bills you should be Aware of.

Our Lobbyist, Mapes and Mapes is actively monitoring these House Bills!

 

House Bill 491 Sponsored by Representative Kathy Edmonston

This bill provides relative to the Life Safety and Property Protection Licensing Act.

It offers an exemption to Felons whose charges are 15 years old.

House Bill 607 Representative Charles Owen

This bill provides relative to the locksmith licensing.

This bill will create new categories of licensure for locksmithing,